How to Keep a Trading Journal That Actually Improves Your Trading
Every trading educator says "keep a journal." Most traders try it for a week, write "took a long on EUR/USD, lost $200" and give up because it doesn't seem helpful.
The problem isn't journaling — it's how traders journal. Here's how to do it right.
What to Track (And What Not To)
Essential Data (Every Trade)
- Instrument and direction (long/short)
- Entry and exit price
- Position size and dollar risk
- P&L in dollars and R-multiples
- Trade duration
- Session (London, New York, Asian)
- Setup type (breakout, pullback, reversal, etc.)
Context Data (Each Trading Day)
- Emotional state before trading: Calm, anxious, excited, tired, frustrated
- Pre-market bias: Were you bullish/bearish/neutral? Why?
- Market conditions: Trending, ranging, volatile, dead
Don't Track
- Every tick of price action
- Lengthy narrative paragraphs for every trade
- Complicated scoring systems with 20+ variables
Keep it simple enough that you'll actually do it consistently.
The Weekly Review (This Is Where the Value Is)
The daily entries are just data collection. The weekly review is where patterns emerge:
Questions to Ask Every Weekend
- What was my win rate this week? Is it consistent with my strategy's expected win rate?
- What was my average R:R? Am I cutting winners short or letting losers run?
- Which sessions were profitable? Should I stop trading certain hours?
- Which setups worked? Which underperformed?
- How did my emotional state correlate with results? Do I trade worse when anxious?
- Did I follow my rules? Count rule violations, not just P&L
Pattern Detection
After 4+ weeks of data, you'll start seeing patterns like:
- "I lose money 80% of the time I trade during NFP"
- "My win rate on breakouts is 35% but on pullbacks it's 60%"
- "I make money Mon–Wed and give it back Thu–Fri"
These insights are worth more than any trading course.
Digital vs. Handwritten
| Method | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheet | Easy to analyze, searchable | Can feel tedious |
| Handwritten | Deeper reflection, better memory | Hard to analyze data |
| Dedicated tool | Automated imports, analytics built in | Monthly cost |
The best approach: automated data import + manual annotations. Let software handle the numbers, and you add the context.
PropTally's trading journal combines both — your trades are imported automatically, and you can add notes, emotional state, setup type, and screenshots to each day or individual trade.
Pre-Market Checklist
Add a daily pre-market checklist to your journal routine:
- [ ] Checked economic calendar for high-impact events
- [ ] Identified key support/resistance levels
- [ ] Defined my bias for the day
- [ ] Set maximum loss limit for the day
- [ ] Physical state: slept well, not distracted
- [ ] Emotional state: calm and focused
If you can't check most of these boxes, consider not trading that day.
Measuring Improvement Over Time
Track these metrics monthly:
- Win rate trend: Is it improving?
- Average R:R trend: Are you improving trade management?
- Rule adherence rate: What percentage of trades follow your rules?
- Emotional trading frequency: How often are you taking unplanned trades?
Improvement isn't always about making more money — sometimes it's about losing less, following rules more consistently, or reducing emotional decisions.
Start Today, Not Tomorrow
The hardest part of journaling is starting. Don't wait for the perfect system. Open a spreadsheet, log today's trades with the basics, and build from there.
The traders who journal consistently for 3+ months almost always report measurable improvement. Those who don't journal keep making the same mistakes.
Start tracking your prop firm payouts
Import trades, monitor drawdowns, and manage multiple funded accounts in one dashboard.
Sign Up Free